Call Us 850-457-3299 ☰ ˟
Logo
Call Us Today 850-457-3299
  • Home
  • Get A Quote
    • Annuities
    • AutomobileImage of right arrow
      • Auto Insurance Quote
      • Auto
    • Bonds
    • Business & CommercialImage of right arrow
      • Commercial Auto Insurance Quote
      • General Liability Quote Form
      • Business Owners (BOP) Quote Form
      • Builders Risk
      • Liquor Liability Quote Form
      • Workers Compensation Quote
    • Flood
    • HomeownersImage of right arrow
      • Homeowners Insurance Quote
      • Manufactured Home Quote
      • Homeowner Flood Quote Form
      • Homeowners Quote
    • Motorcycle
    • Recreational Vehicle
    • Renters
    • Watercraft & Boat
    • Windstorm
  • Customer Service
    • Online Account Access
    • AutomobileImage of right arrow
      • Request ID Card for Auto Policy
      • Request Declaration and Coverages Page for Auto Policy
      • Send Declaration and Coverages Information to Lien Holder
      • Add Vehicle to Existing Auto Policy
      • Remove Vehicle from Existing Auto Policy
      • Add Driver to Existing Auto Policy
      • Remove Driver from Existing Auto Policy
    • Business & CommercialImage of right arrow
      • Request ID Card for Commercial Auto Policy
      • Request Declaration and Coverages Page for Commercial Auto Policy
      • Add Vehicle to Existing Commercial Auto Policy
      • Remove Vehicle from Existing Commercial Auto Policy
      • Add Driver to Existing Commercial Auto Policy
      • Remove Driver from Existing Commercial Auto Policy
      • Request General Liability Certificate of Insurance
    • Flood
    • HomeownersImage of right arrow
      • Request Declaration and Coverages for Existing Homeowners Insurance Coverage
      • Request Evidence of Insurance
    • MotorcycleImage of right arrow
      • Request ID Card for Motorcycle Policy
      • Request Declaration and Coverages Page for Motorcycle Policy
      • Add Motorcycle to Existing Policy
      • Remove Motorcycle from Existing Policy
      • Add Driver to Existing Motorcycle Policy
      • Remove Driver from Existing Motorcycle Policy
    • Other
    • Recreational VehicleImage of right arrow
      • Request ID Card for Recreational Vehicle Policy
      • Request Declaration and Coverages Page for Recreational Vehicle Policy
      • Add Recreational Vehicle to Existing Policy
      • Remove Recreational Vehicle from Existing Policy
      • Add Driver to Existing Recreational Vehicle Policy
      • Remove Driver from Existing Recreational Vehicle Policy
    • Renters
    • Watercraft & BoatImage of right arrow
      • Request ID Card for Watercraft Policy
      • Request Declaration and Coverages Page for Watercraft Policy
      • Add Watercraft to Existing Policy
      • Remove Watercraft from Existing Policy
      • Change Primary Operator on Existing Watercraft Policy
    • Windstorm
  • Blog
  • Make a Payment
  • Resources
    • Secure File Area
    • Refer a Friend
    • Important Links
    • Calculators
    • Important Files
    • Free Reports
    • Insurance Glossary
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • News Center
  • About Us
    • About Coggins Insurance Agency
    • Location Map
    • Employee Directory
    • Partners
    • Customer Testimonials
    • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
Home > Blog > Injunction of PIP law could pave way to elimination of no-fault insurance
THURSDAY, MARCH 21, 2013

Injunction of PIP law could pave way to elimination of no-fault insurance

A Leon County judge struck down parts of new law designed to lower costs and root out fraud in personal injury protection (PIP) claims on Wednesday, potentially pushing lawmakers to get rid of Florida’s no-fault system.

Sen. Joe Negron, R-Stuart, who sponsored the Senate version of last year’s HB 119, said Judge Terry Lewis’s temporary injunction striking down a $2,500 cap on non-emergency care and a 14-day deadline for treatment have him thinking about a plan to eliminate the PIP system in favor of mandatory bodily injury coverage. That idea was first floated by Sen. David Simmons, R-Maitland.

“I think this is an ideal time to look to Sen. Simmons to explore his bill ditching PIP and instead going toward a mandatory (bodily injury) system,” Negron said.

Under current law, PIP coverage provides up to $10,000 worth of coverage for injuries sustained in a car accident regardless of the party at fault. With bodily injury coverage, the insurance company of the party at fault in an accident would pay claims.

HB 119 passed the Senate by one vote on the last day of session last year under heavy lobbying from Gov. Rick Scott’s office. In addition to the non-emergency care cap and two-week treatment deadline, the law prohibits chiropractors and massage therapists from being compensated under PIP claims, which typically stem from automobile accidents. The law also takes aim at fraud, which supporters of the law say is responsible for an inflation of nearly $1 billion in auto insurance costs.

In a released statement, Scott said he would appeal the ruling.

"Our personal injury protection legislation was designed to stop the high costs passed on to Florida families by car insurance companies because of excessive lawsuits, waste and fraud," Scott said. "Our reforms are working to lower insurance costs for Florida families and we will continue to fight special interest groups to keep them in place."

Auto insurers warned lawsuits testing the new law would temper rate decreases, but studies predicted large drops in auto rates. Along with Negron, Chief Financial Officer Jeff Atwater complained insurers weren’t reducing rates enough when initial rate filings started to flow in.

Massage therapists and chiropractors challenged the law as unconstitutional, but were not granted a temporary injunction at the federal court level. Wednesday’s ruling gives them more hope, but insurers more heartburn.

Negron said his main reason for supporting the law was to reduce auto insurance rates, not to “provide a windfall for the industry.”

“I have every confidence that he could work with (the Senate Banking and Insurance Committee) to seriously explore replacement of the PIP system with mandatory (bodily injury),” Negron said. “But those are options. We’re certainly not going to make final decisions based on a temporary injunction.”

After speaking with reporters in his office late Wednesday, Negron headed to Simmons’ office.

Related Research: March 18, 2013 Order granting in part motion for temporary injunction in Case No. 2013CA73 before the Second Judicial Circuit Court of Florida.

Reporter Gray Rohrer can be reached at grohrer@thefloridacurrent.com.

Filed in: Insurance
Tags: FL Governor Rick Scott, Fraud, Insurance Rates, Personal Injury Protection
Posted 12:03 PM

Share |


No Comments


Post a Comment
Required
Required (Not Displayed)
Required


All comments are moderated and stripped of HTML.

NOTICE: This blog and website are made available by the publisher for educational and informational purposes only. It is not be used as a substitute for competent insurance, legal, or tax advice from a licensed professional in your state. By using this blog site you understand that there is no broker client relationship between you and the blog and website publisher.
Blog Archive
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013

  • independent insurance agent(5)
  • insurance quotes(4)
  • florida drivers(4)
  • auto insurance(4)
  • pensacola insurance agent(2)
  • liability insurance(1)
  • insurance premium(1)
  • homeowners insurance(1)
  • premium audit(1)
  • rental car insurance(1)
  • homeowner's insurance(1)
  • insurance audit(1)
  • workers compensation(1)
  • liability(1)
  • florida homeowner(1)
  • independent agent(1)
  • insurance quote(1)
  • bbb.org(1)
  • insurance policy(1)
  • replacement cost(1)
  • #laborday(1)
  • commercial insurance(1)
  • insurance score(1)

View Mobile Version
Logo

504 S. Fairfield Drive Suite A-1
Pensacola, FL 32506
Ph: 850-457-3299
Fx: 850-457-2181

Facebook Icon Twitter Icon
© Copyright. All rights reserved | Powered by Insurance Website Builder